
…that phrase often comes out of my mouth (and I suppose anyone and everyone that likes music) as soon as the beat drops and you recognize the start of a song. A guitar riff, a drum beat, an opening line…and you’re all excited at the prospect of listening, waiting for your favourite line, singing along…whatever rocks your boat.
It’s interesting that in our music-saturated world, the same attitude we have towards songs on the radio can be the same attitude we have towards songs of corporate worship we sing in church. You’ve done it before – you get a new CD, put it on repeat for 2.5 weeks, then don’t want to see it or hear of it for 12 months. After a year, you listen to the CD again and fall back in love with the music. I do it all the time, although I usually last about 4-6 months with the stuff on repeat…which is just not good for anybody.
We’re blessed to have some amazing song-writers and great songs in the church. I currently attend a church renowned for its corporate worship songs. The people who lead worship on an average Sunday service here literally sell out stadiums around the world, with thousands paying just for the experience of seeing these guys play music (well, it’s not JUST playing music, but the point is people pay to see them). Anyway, the music is great, and the songs are just churned out year after year.
So a few days ago, a chap I know commented about how he was “so over” a certain song we sing at church, pretty much because he’s heard and sung a lot over the past years. It got me thinking whether it should be possible for that to happen with a corporate worship song. I think it’s fair to assume that most people would go ahead and just say, “Of course, if you play a song every week, people will eventually get tired of it…that’s common sense. We need to make sure the music coming from the stage is always fresh (and yes, I got the memo in Psalms about singing a new song to the Lord).”
Well, I see at least 2 problems with that sort of statement.
Firstly, the assumption is that the primary weight of the song comes through in the musical characteristics (melody, beat, etc). That’s to say, as soon as you recognise the song, what starts to stand out over time is the musical landscape and structure.
Secondly, the statement assumes that you make the ultimate decision as to the timeliness and usefulness of the song (i.e. when you recognise the song, and that thought comes, “YES! I love this song!”….OR….”Oh man, not THIS song, we’ve sung this thing the past 3 weeks straight! Why aren’t we singing [insert favourite song name here]…..” – you know what I’m saying…the thought has occured to all of us).
First, I think to assume that the weight of a corporate worship song lies in the musical make-up is erroneous. This pretty clear because we don’t just stand around and listen to instrumentals during corporate singing time – we need to sing words. The weight lies in the words. There is a power in what the words communicate. The music supports the words. I’m no worship leader, but that’s my opinion. This isn’t to say you can’t play instrumentals to the glory of God…I’m just not sure you can play in that fashion for a whole corporate worship time. With this in mind, the resulting view we should have of a song should ask questions like, “What is this song saying? What do the words communicate? Are the words true?”.
When it comes to our own feelings about certain songs, the timeliness and usefulness issues (at the root of it) can sometimes highlight the consumer nature of corporate worship. When the first thing we think about is our feelings when it comes to worship, there’s something wrong. CJ Mahaney points to this error in his book, ‘Christ Our Mediator – Finding Passion at the Cross’. While in this passage he’s primarily talking about Scripture, the same applies to music. He says:
“Our common tendency is to habitually begin with the internal, the subjective, the experiential, then use those feelings and impressions to determine what we’ll accept a being objective fact. We let our feelings tell us what is true, instead of letting the truth transform our feelings.”
How true - it’s so often about how we feel instead of what the song says, the truth it speaks that should transform what we feel, bring out our affections for Christ and what He has done for us.
So next time I hear a song I’ve heard over and over, I’m going to try focus on the glorious words first of all. I’m convinced the truth they speak will transform my feelings.
R.O.O.